ATMP Issue #2
Welcome to the 1st edition of the CREATIC ATMP Newsletter!
The CREATIC ATMP newsletter gives you a window to the rapidly evolving regulatory and ethical landscape for therapies utilizing genes-, cells and tissue. Youwill find a collection of news regulatory developments and discussions spiced up with perspectives and analysis – all with a focus on legal and ethical issues.
The newsletter will be published quarterly, with the next issue being scheduled forJanuary. If you're interested in staying updated on the latest legal and ethical newsrelated to ATMPs, please sign up here.
News
End of the transition period for the new Clinical Trials Regulation (CTR)
The Strategic Imperative: Why Early Potency Assay Development Makes or Breaks ATMP Success
One Size Does Not Fit All: EU, UK, and U.S.Regulatory Developments in the Age of Precision Medicine
First outcome-based agreement for an ATMP in the Nordic Region
New platform for cross-border medical discussions on rare diseases
UK to Implement one ofa kind Framework for Point-Of-Care Manufacturing
Health Technology Assessment Regulation (HTAR)
Navigating the launch of ATMPs in Europe: Q&A interview
HTA - Commission adopts rulesfor joint scientific consultationson medicinal products forhuman use
New EU rules on Health Technology Assessment open up a new era for patient access to innovation
Monthly opinion
Challenges and Opportunities in Expanding CAR T-Cell Therapy Access in Czechia
Papers
Commentary: Risk-based pricing models and therole they might play in patients' access to new stemcell therapies
Call for More Effective Regulation of Clinical Trials with ATMPs Consisting of or Containing GMOs in the EU
Identification of the conditions and minimum requirements necessary for the release of autologous fresh CAR T-cell products under hospital exemption: a position paper from the WP-bioproduction of the UNITC consortium
Webinars
The EU HTA Regulation: Webinar for health technology developers of medicinal products
From Theory to Practice: Implementing the EU Health Technology Assessment Regulation
Conversations on Cancer - Pediatric Cancers: Navigating the Challenges Together
Translating innovation into access for ATMPs: third EU-Innovation network multi-stakeholder meeting
ATMPs regulatory overview - Scientific Symposium on Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products - ‘Contribution, evolution, revolution'
Upcoming events
What you can look forward to.
CREATIC celebrates its first year since the start of the teaming project! The CREATICCentre of Excellence of the Faculty of Medicine of Masaryk University in Brno was established on 1 January 2024. Since January 1, 2024, CREATIC has held the title of a scientific excellence center focusing on development, research, production and innovation under its Lékařská fakulta Masarykovy University.
During the first year, CREATIC have reached several important milestones:
- Built a research center with 7 platforms
- Established cooperation with university hospital
- Started the conversion of the clean room for GMP production, which will strengthen the research capacity
- Established and data unit in collaboration on bioinformatic analyses
- Collaborated with the Outpatient Clinic for Pediatric Patients without Diagnosis of Fakultní nemocnice Brno and created a patient register
CREATIC's plans for the next year includes expansion of research projects, support for education and preparation of accreditation for PhD programmes 🔬👩🔬
For more updates follow CREATIC on Linkedin.
End of the transition period for the new Clinical Trials Regulation (CTR)
The beginning of the year comes with important changes. 30 Jan 2025 marks the end of the transition period for the new Clinical Trials Regulation (CTR). From 31 January 2025, all clinical trials conducted in the EU must comply with the Clinical Trials Regulation. This means that during trials necessary information on the trial must be recorded in the Clinical Trials Information System (CTIS), to avoid the risk of the trial being considered non-compliant once the transitional period is over.
The Strategic Imperative: Why Early Potency Assay Development Makes or Breaks ATMP Success
Early potency assay development is of critical importance in the creation of ATMPs. Not developing potency assays and gaining knowledge about MOAs early in the drug development process can break ATMP success and cause costs and delays. Two Biologics License Applications (BLAs) has already been rejected. To avoid this, it is recommended that developers initiate potency assay development early. This proactive strategy can significantly streamline the development and regulatory approval process for ATMPs.
One Size Does Not Fit All: EU, UK, and U.S.Regulatory Developments in the Age of Precision Medicine
Due to advancements in precision medicine, including gene and cell therapies, regulators are grappling with how to best regulate the manufacture of advanced therapies in a way that supports development, whilst also ensuring an appropriate level of regulation and safety. The EU, UK, and U.S are all facing challenges and taking initiatives to adapt existing frameworks to accommodate advancements inpersonalized treatments, such as gene and cell therapies. The article explores regulatory the different initiatives and approaches in the EU, UK and the U.S.
First outcome-based agreement for an ATMP in the Nordic Region
CSL Behring Signs Milestone Commercial outcome-based agreement with Amgros, the Danish procurement authority, to Fund Haemophilia B Gene Therapy HEMGENIX in Denmark. Denmark is the first country in the Nordic region to reimburse under a performance-based model, in which the regions only incur costs if the gene therapy proves effective over an agreed long-term period.
New platform for cross-border medical discussions on rare diseases
The Commission has launched a new IT platform for cross-border medical discussions on rare diseases.The Clinical Patient Management System 2.0 (CPMS 2.0) will support the European Reference Networks (ERNs) in improving the diagnosis and treatment of rare or low prevalence complex diseases across Member States.
UK to Implement one ofa kind Framework for Point-Of-Care Manufacturing
The UK's Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency has announced a first-of-its-kind legislation to better facilitate manufacturing and delivery to patients of medicines that are manufactured at or near the patient's bedside. The UK aims to enable increased access for patients to some of the most innovative medicines currently available.
Health Technology Assessment Regulation (HTAR)
On Sunday, 12 January, the Regulation on Health Technology Assessment (HTAR) became fully applicable. ATMPs are therefore among the first to undergo joint clinical assessments at EU level in 2025 and these will form the basis for national value assessments and pricing negotiations.
Navigating the launch of ATMPs in Europe: Q&A interview
Providing an overview of the European Union's new health technology assessment (HTA) regulation and Joint Clinical Assessment (JCA) process, Experts Lung-ICheng and Herbert Altmann discuss the overarching objectives of EU HTA-R and delves into the key criteria used to assess pharmaceuticals in Europe, variations across member states, and the pivotal role of HTAs in determining reimbursement and market accessibility, in particular for ATMPs.
The experts, also shed light on the shifts inregulation and the strategies essential for successful navigation of the new regulationon the EU Health Technology Assessment for ATMPs and oncology drugs.
HTA - Commission adopts rulesfor joint scientific consultationson medicinal products forhuman use
The European Commission has adopted an implementing regulation setting out the rules for joint scientific consultations on medicinal products for human use at Union level, under the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) Regulation. The implementing act provides detailed procedural rules for the joint scientific consultations.
You can find the Procedural Guidance for Joint Scientific Consultations (JSC) on Medicinal Products (MP).
What is HTA?
HTA is a procedure for assessing the added value, effectiveness, costs and broader impact of healthcare interventions including medicines, medical devices and procedures.
New EU rules on Health Technology Assessment open up a new era for patient access to innovation
Three reports published by EFPIA show disparities in the time it takes for European patients to access new medicines persist. The reports show that patients in one country can wait more than 6 times as long as patients in a neighbouring country for medicines that received marketing authorization at the same time. Patients in Germany wait on average, 126 days for a new product following marketing authorization. In Poland, the gap between authorization and availability is up to 804 days. The reasons for unavailability and delays, are multifactorial and are often due to a combination of factors, however the speed of health technology assessments is one of these factors.
The European Union's Health Technology Assessment Regulation regulation aims to improvethe availability of innovative medicines across Europe. The regulation is expected to bring significant improvement in ensuring that innovative and effective health technologies are available to patients across the EU. It is furthermore expected to contribute to faster and wideraccess to new and more effective innovative products for patients.
Challenges and Opportunities in Expanding CAR T-Cell Therapy Access in Czechia
PharmDr. Zora Čechová, Ph.D. Regulatory Specialist, MUNI | CREATIC
CAR T-cell therapies have revolutionised the treatment of haematological malignancies since their introductionto the market in 2018. Czechia is at the forefront of adopting these innovative treatments in Central andEastern Europe, with three out of six authorised CAR T-cell therapies already available to patients. The othertwo therapies, Abecma (idecabtagene vicleucel) and Breyanzi (lisocabtagene maraleucel) have had theirmaximum prices determined and are nearing rollout. However, this progress also introduces significantchallenges, especially with regard to multiple myeloma treatment with Abecma.
Despite substantial advancements, multiple myeloma remains an incurable disease with increasing incidenceand prevalence. Approximately 550 new cases are diagnosed annually in Czechia. While advances in therapyhave extended survival, most patients relapse and require subsequent treatment lines, driving demand forAbecma as a third-line treatment. The estimates approach one hundred patients per year.
Several bottlenecks remain in delivering this highly personalised treatment to patients who need it, startingwith the complex, patient-specific manufacturing process, which requires careful coordination to ensure thetimely availability of manufacturing slots. Additionally, although there are nine specialized centres certified toadminister CAR T-cell products in Czechia, these facilities may still face personnel and capacity constraints asthe number of eligible patients continues to grow.
Pricing and reimbursement procedures present another significant challenge. Although the State Institute ofDrug Control has determined the maximum price for Abecma, a formal reimbursement procedure, includinghealth technology assessment, is not required for medicinal products administered solely in inpatient settings.These products, including CAR T-cell, are available to Czech patients within all EMA-approved indications, theyare fully covered by public health insurance, and patients do not contribute to their financing. However, thismight not be sufficient to cover the full financing from payers to healthcare providers, as it is secured only upto the limit calculated based on the year before last. Therefore, budget planning does not account forunexpected increases in demand for new treatment options, such as Abecma for treating multiple myelomapatients. Further, as the high cost of CAR T-cell treatments adds pressure to the healthcare budget, to mitigatethe financial burden, arrangements between manufacturers and payers are essential. So far, the only type ofagreement used to limit the budget impact of ATMPs is price reduction agreements. Value-based pricingmodels, where financing aligns with clinical outcomes, offer a potential solution but require complexnegotiations. However, the lack of healthcare digitalisation remains a key barrier in Czechia to implementingsuch agreements effectively.
A cohesive strategy involving all stakeholders – clinicians, healthcare providers, regulators, payers, andmanufacturers – is essential to address these challenges. Collaboration will be critical to ensuring broaderpatient access without compromising the quality of care.
Commentary: Risk-based pricing models and therole they might play in patients' access to new stemcell therapies
Stem cell research is currently undergoing a promising transformation from primarily basic research to increasing emphasis on translation and clinical trials. To reach patients, however, stem cell treatments need to be not only technically but also economically viable. This commentry presents insights into emerging pricing models that may help ensure access to advanced and expensive treatments like stem cell therapies. It further, presents some reflections on the practical and ethical challenges that these models involve.
Regenerative Medicine, 19(12), 589–593. Published 18 December 2024
Call for More Effective Regulation of Clinical Trials with ATMPs Consisting of or Containing GMOs in the EU
ATMPs therapies that consist of or containgenetically modified organisms (GMOs) need to comply with the European Union GMO legislation, as implemented in each EU Member State, before a clinical trial can commence. Complying with GMO requirements is complex, varies significantly across EU Member States and is leading to delays to clinical trials with ATMPs. Such delays and varying implementation of the GMO legislation makes the EU less attractive as a region to conduct clinical trials with investigational gene therapies. This is detrimental to EU patients, since their timely access to these transformative potentially curative medicines is delayed. The Alliance for Regenerative Medicine, the European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations, and the European Association for Bio industries call upon the EC, together with national competent authorities, to exempt ATMPs containing or consisting of GMOs from the GMO legislation.
Human Gene Therapy Volume 32, Number 19-20, 2021
Towards implementing new payment models for there imbursement of high-cost, curative therapies in Europe: insights from semi-structured interviews
Standard reimbursement systems face many challenges when dealing with reimbursement applications for potential one-time high-cost therapies like ATMPs, which has led to managed entry agreements (MEAs) being the standard tool in various countries. The use of MEAs was intended to be an exception; however, their widespread application is placing pressure on health systems. This has inspired the development of alternative payment structures, such as payer reinsurance, pooling budgets, spread (annuity-based) payments, and outcome-based agreements (OBAs) to mitigate the unaffordability of high-cost, one-time, and possibly curative therapies.
This study aimed to elicit opinions on and insights into the governance aspect of implementing outcome-based spread payments (OBSP) in Belgium for there imbursement of innovative therapies
Front. Pharmacol., 20 January 2025
Identification of the conditions and minimum requirements necessary for the release of autologous fresh CAR T-cell products under hospital exemption: a position paper from the WP-bioproduction of the UNITC consortium
What are the conditions and requirements necessary for the release of fresh CAR-Tcells in terms of the final products' characteristics, safety, and potency?
The accessibility of CAR-T cells in centralized production models faces significantchallenges, primarily stemming from logistical complexities and prohibitive costs. The hospital exemption enables academic institutions to produce ATMPs under GMP conditions tailored to specific needs. In response to this regulatory framework, a work group has launched a guideline initiative. This inaugural focused on delineating criteria for the release of fresh CAR-T cell batches. Key emphases included thorough product characterization, stringent safety and potency evaluations. These criteria are essential for compliance with regulatory mandates and aligning with industry best practices.
Bone Marrow Transplant (2025). Published 25 January 2025.
The EU HTA Regulation: Webinar for health technology developers of medicinal products
Member State Coordination Group on Health Technology Assessment explain the process for joint clinical assessments and joint scientific consultations. The webinar is targeted at representatives of health technology developers of medicinal products
From Theory to Practice: Implementing the EU Health Technology Assessment Regulation
Stakeholder event focused on the implementation of the European Union's Health Technology Assessment (HTA) Regulation.
Conversations on Cancer - Pediatric Cancers: Navigating the ChallengesTogether
A one-hour Conversations on Cancer public panel discussion, to examine an array of challenging decisions faced by members of the pediatric oncology community.
Translating innovation into access for ATMPs: third EU-Innovation network multi-stakeholder meeting
A multi-stakeholder meeting to discuss how innovation in the development of Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMPs) can be translated into effective and safe therapies at the point of carein Europe.
ATMPs regulatory overview - Scientific Symposium on Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products - ‘Contribution, evolution, revolution'
A symposium that showcases how the work of Committee for Advanced Therapies (CAT) has contributed to the regulatory framework for ATMPs in Europe, its adaptation to the challenge sposed by novel classes of ATMPs and how CAT has contributed to the approval of ATMPs.
Webinar | 19-02-2025 to 20-02-2035
ACT EU workshop on ICH E6 R3 (principles and Annex 1)
Course | 24-02-2025 to 28-02-2035
ADVANCE Course on Cell and Gene Therapies 2025
Conference | 27-02-2025
RegMed Forum 2025: Process development and translation of ATMP projects
Summit | 12-03-2025
The fourth edition of the Dutch ATMP Summit is organized around the theme of Automation in ATMP manufacturing
Conference | 18-03-2025 to 19-03-2025
The Advanced Therapies Congress
Our newsletter shares the latest developments, changes, and discussions in the world of ATMP's and keep youupdated on our upcoming events and initiatives with a special focus on Social Science and Humanities (SSH)including legal and regulatory issues.
For further information about CREATIC, contact Jakob Wested: jakob.wested@jur.ku.dk
For further information about the newsletter, publication of events, opinion and commentaries, contactmanaging editor Emma Schou Nielsen: vzk859@jur.ku.dk.
Link to CREATIC homepage. Created in cooperation with Masaryk University.
This is an archived issue, therefore we cannot guarantee that the links will work.